Greatest Building in the History of World Architecture

To control SPAM, you must now be a registered user to post to this Message Board.

EFFECTIVE 14 Nov. 2012 PRIVATE MESSAGING HAS BEEN RE-ENABLED. IF YOU RECEIVE A SUSPICIOUS DO NOT CLICK ON ANY LINKS AND PLEASE REPORT TO THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION.

This is the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy's Message Board. Wright enthusiasts can post questions and comments, and other people visiting the site can respond.

You agree not to post any abusive, obscene, vulgar, slanderous, hateful, threatening, *-oriented or any other material that may violate any applicable laws. Doing so may lead to you being immediately and permanently banned (and your service provider being informed). The IP address of all posts is recorded to aid in enforcing these conditions. You agree that the webmaster, administrator and moderators of this forum have the right to remove, edit, move or close any topic at any time they see fit.
Post Reply
pharding
Posts: 2252
Joined: Sat Jun 25, 2005 5:19 pm
Location: River Forest, Illinois
Contact:

Greatest Building in the History of World Architecture

Post by pharding »

Based upon my numerous pilgrimages to Europe and throughout the US to see firsthand many of the greatest architectural works, I believe that the finest building in the history of world architecture is Fallingwater. I was there again last week so I had an opportunity to reacquaint myself with the building. This is what makes Fallingwater so spectacular in comparison to other great buildings.



First of all it has an incredibly bold "big idea". The idea of cantilevering the building off of the rock formations and hanging it out over the waterfall so that the house is part of the waterfall instead of just looking at it is both innovative and brilliant. In order to achieve this a technical "tour de force" was created. Another aspect of the siting which is underappreciated until you see it firsthand is the approach to the building. One walks along the original automobile drive which curves through the lush forested setting. The drive curves to a close in view corridor that creates an incredible vista of the house with the bridge in the foreground. In person this view of the building is more impressive than the classic Hedrich Blessing view of the house hovering over the waterfall. You also see the stepping action of the building's section as it steps up with the hillside. This stepping motif repeats elsewhere in the design. The drive takes you around back to a wonderful space that is created by the house and a vertical rock formation. The wall of the house uses a wonderful local field stone that resonates with the stone rock formation. In plan the stepping motif is reintroduced here.



One enters the house after passing underneath concrete trellis that will repeat on the waterfall side of the house. Using an idea that originally appeared at his home and studio the trellis is built around two live trees. One enters into a receiving room that conceptually originated with FLW's Prairie Houses forty years earlier. A short flight of stairs takes you up to the main level of the house. The living room is an unbelievable space for many reasons. First of all the sound of the waterfall resonates throughout the space. One is reintroduced to the stone of the site, by a stone formation that rises up through the stone floor at the fireplace. Ribbon windows with a variety of patterns introduce daylight and offer views to the lush setting. A stair cascades down to the water below so that you come in first hand contact with the stream. The glass enclosure gives you views right down to the stream so that you can see exactly where you are. The fireplace has a wonderful steel sphere that never worked as intended but works well as a sculpture against the stone of the fireplace. The stepping motif again repeats itself at the other side of the fireplace.



The incredible architectural energy extends throughout the rest of the house. The bedrooms and designed in an incredibly skillful and architecturally rich manner that far exceeds his more straightforward Prairie House bedrooms. What is particularly special is the way that FLW now embraces asymmetry in these bedrooms. This is especially interesting with the built in head boards and night stands.



What I found fascinating are the many Prairie House ideas and concepts that FLW used here. The blend of his Prairie School aesthetic with the new freedom of the International Style resonates throughout the house to create an architecture that is incredibly innovative, warm, and appropriate. Prairie House concepts include semi-pinwheel massing which creates a wonderful implied outdoor space. The concealed entry and the processional experience. The hearth as the center of the house. The honest use of materials. Banding of interior shelves to display artwork and bric brac. Built-in furniture. Terraces. Stairs wrapping screen elements. Integration of lighting and mechanical systems into the architecture. Built-in millwork for storage as opposed to closets. In general the detailing vaguely recalls the prairie Houses. With the influence of the international style FLW pushes his kit of parts acquired and developed over decades to a new architectural expression.



The house is also noteworthy because it is one of the few FLW buildings fully intact with the original site, building, furniture, artwork, and personal furnishings.



Where the design falls slightly short is design of the building housing the guest quarters, servants, and cars. This building looses some of the architectural richness of the house itself.



All of this contributes to the greatest architectural work in world history.
Paul Harding FAIA Owner and Restoration Architect for FLW's 1901 E. Arthur Davenport House, the First Prairie School House in Chicago | www.harding.com | LinkedIn

jackless

Post by jackless »

i enjoy Fallingwater as much as the next person, and think's it's a great architectural design, but there are other buildings I would have to place above it on any list (not particularly in any order):



St Peter's Basilica

St Paul's Cathedral - London

Empire State Building

Taj Mahal

US Capital Building

Versailles Palace

pharding
Posts: 2252
Joined: Sat Jun 25, 2005 5:19 pm
Location: River Forest, Illinois
Contact:

Other Great Buildings

Post by pharding »

Here are some other buildings that approach Fallingwater as great architectural works in my opinion. I am limiting my choices to the buildings that I have personally visited.



Salk Institute by Louis Kahn.

Saynatsalo Town Hall by Alvar Aalto.

First Church of Christ, Scientist in Berkely by Bernard Maybeck.

Villa Savoy by Le Corbusier.

Exeter Library by Louis Kahn.

Robie House by Frank Lloyd Wright.

Crane Library by H.H. Richardson.

Kaufman House by Richard Neutra.

Tredyffrin Public Library by Mitchell/Giurgola.

Farnsworth House by Mies van der Rohe.

Jubilee Church by Richard Meier.

Padre Pio Pilgramage Church by Renzo Piano.



The coomon denominator in all of these great buildings is the incredible fit between the architecture and the program. They all have a compelling sense of appropriateness.



More to be added later.
Paul Harding FAIA Owner and Restoration Architect for FLW's 1901 E. Arthur Davenport House, the First Prairie School House in Chicago | www.harding.com | LinkedIn

Mobius
Posts: 149
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 7:20 pm
Location: Christchurch, New Zealand
Contact:

Post by Mobius »

IANAA - and I don't have a huge wealth of experience to draw upon, but I believe Mr. Harding to be correct. I have 3 books on Fallingwater, and a DVD.



I think the story of the mad drawing session, from nothing except ideas, in the time it took Edgar to drive to the studio, coupled with the radical construction, and even the errors when pouring the main floor slab (forgetting to allow for deflection, something which bugged Kaufmann his whole life) all combine to make it the greatest building ever.



The story of the design and construction alone is epic, without even beginning to discuss its impact over the years.



So yeah, I think it possibly is.



The only problem is, when discussing "greatest", it always needs ot be qaulified in some way. "Greatest dwelling", or "greatest influence", or "Most recoignised" - all these things are easier to find, than simply "the greatest". That is an entirely open ended question.
How many escape pods are there? "NONE, SIR!" You counted them? "TWICE, SIR!"

*Plotting to take over the world since 1965

Roderick Grant
Posts: 9864
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 7:48 am

Post by Roderick Grant »

About the only building that I would place above Fallingwater is Taliesin. If architecture is frozen music, Fallingwater is Beethoven's Fifth, while Taliesin is the Ninth, or maybe Bach's B Minor Mass! But I wouldn't melt either one to find out. Of non-FLW buildings in the vicinity of FW, though not necessarily above it, I agree on Saynatsalo Town Hall and would add Villa Mareia (sp?), but would disagree with Villa Savoy in favor of Notre Dame du Ronchamps. Savoy may be the most overrated building of the 20th Century. Savoy is better as a place to Stomp! The finest government building in the U. S. is the state capitol at Lincoln, Nebraska, by Goodhue, which is also one of the finest skyscrapers. Both Eliel Saarinen and Norway's Sverre Fehn are underrated masters. In spite of the alterations by idiotic bureaucrats and elected officials, and Jorn Utzon's replacement as achitect, the Sydney Opera House is as iconic as the Eiffel Tower. Of the younger crowd, Will Bruder's Phoenix Public Library holds its own.

Roderick Grant
Posts: 9864
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 7:48 am

Post by Roderick Grant »

... and one more of my favorites, a true modern masterpiece: Maison Dalsace in Paris by Chareau.

Richard
Posts: 76
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 2:29 pm
Location: Illinois

Post by Richard »

Thank god that no one mentioned anything by Philip Johnson...
Homeowner

JimM
Posts: 1509
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 5:44 pm
Location: Austin,Texas

Post by JimM »

Fallingwater stands alone as a tour de force of residential design. I think I have made 8 trips, including 2 all day hitchhikes while in high school. A friend judged it unlivable due to the lack of enough electrical outlets!



One aspect of Fallingwater misunderstood is its similarity to the modernists, due only to the apparent "white" terraces. This is totally untrue. Although the clean exterior lines and daring cantilevers are "modern", the interiors actually reveal the familiar, consistent attention to detailing found in all of Wright's work; absent and deemed "Wrong" by the modernists. By "out-moderning" the modernists, while at the same time infusing the house with his unique elements, Wright made Fallingwater the icon it has deservedly become.



Still, I think Taliesin is more important. Broken record time: Taliesin 1 was the original complete manifestation of house, site, and program, as opposed to the experimental laboratory and amalgamation Taliesin eventually became.



James Cutler and Ricardo Legoretta are two of the best site specific/original thinkers. The only context of mentioning St. Peter's/FLLW, is that Michaelangelo, like Frank, pushed into the unknown: He could not structurally engineer the dome with stone, so a huge chain is holding it in compression. Kind of like the steel flitches holding up the wooden carports!

Wrightgeek
Posts: 1548
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 5:21 pm
Location: Westerville, Ohio

Post by Wrightgeek »

I certainly cannot take exception with any discussion that places Fallingwater at the top of a list of great architectural achievements.



Based solely upon the buildings I have had the priviledge to experience, I would include in that discussion, in no particular order along with Fallingwater, the Pantheon and the Colisseum in Rome, Unity Temple, the Kaufmann residence in Palm Springs, and last but certainly not least, Thorncrown Chapel by Fay Jones in Arkansas.



While not quite worthy of this discussion, I would also like to make mention of another spectacular place of worship that I feel is often overlooked, the Chapel of the Holy Cross in Sedona, Arizona. Along those lines, the central worship space within the Unitarian Meeting House is worth mentioning as well.



Remember, this list is based entirely on those structures I have seen in person. With that said, I look forward to reaction and comments.

Reidy
Posts: 1571
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 3:30 pm
Location: Fremont CA

Post by Reidy »

Nearly everything here is twentieth-century. You'd have to include the Gothic cathedrals; maybe a catchall category or, to pick my favorite of those I've seen, Chartres.



Ste. Chapelle, a small Gothic church in Paris, also deserves mention. Another that hasn't come up is Schindler's Lovell beach house.



Fallingwater stays at the top, though.





Peter

Collinst3
Posts: 42
Joined: Fri Jan 06, 2006 4:23 pm
Location: Lebanon, OH

Post by Collinst3 »

In the context of the time innovative buildings or structures where built and the tools that where available, I continue to fascinated by Mayan and Inca structures
Tony Collins
___________
FLW addiction recently fed by building a wright-inspired ranch designed by former senior Taliesin Fellow.

Roderick Grant
Posts: 9864
Joined: Wed Mar 29, 2006 7:48 am

Post by Roderick Grant »

Amien would get my vote as greatest Gothic cathedral. It's one of the few whose architect is known, Robert de Luzarches, and represents the style at its best: not too early with heavy Romanesque features like Durham, not too late with all the fancy fuss of Churriguera's masterpiece at Borgos in Spain. And it is an engineering marvel. Chartres is also wonderful, a sort of Gothic sampler with bits and pieces spanning the entire era, from the early choir to the late north spire. Henry Adams' book "Mont Saint-Michel and Chartres" is a "must-have" for anyone serious about architectural history.

PNB
Posts: 105
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 10:12 am

Post by PNB »

I personally don't think that there is such a thing as the greatest in any category but I would place Taliesin at the top of my personal list with Fallingwater and the Johnson Wax building also near the top. However, I have many great buildings I have yet to see.

Post Reply