EFFECTIVE 14 Nov. 2012 PRIVATE MESSAGING HAS BEEN RE-ENABLED. IF YOU RECEIVE A SUSPICIOUS DO NOT CLICK ON ANY LINKS AND PLEASE REPORT TO THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION.
This is the Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy's Message Board. Wright enthusiasts can post questions and comments, and other people visiting the site can respond.
You agree not to post any abusive, obscene, vulgar, slanderous, hateful, threatening, *-oriented or any other material that may violate any applicable laws. Doing so may lead to you being immediately and permanently banned (and your service provider being informed). The IP address of all posts is recorded to aid in enforcing these conditions. You agree that the webmaster, administrator and moderators of this forum have the right to remove, edit, move or close any topic at any time they see fit.
The most offensive element appears to be the chevron windows. They are somewhat weird but do not stand alone among the forms of the building. What's the alternative if the client insisted on natural basement light, portholes?
Without a quality comparison to Fallingwater, the arrangement of fireplace, seating, dining, and terrace are quite similar. Take a look.
If the heat from the fireplace is uncomfortable to diners, they must have roasted in Willey. If Hildebrand's assessment of Wrightian space is correct, the fireplace opposite the outlook is correct. The fireplace along the path of living space entry is to me its weakest feature, but is a tradeoff to its excellent sense of presence in the space.
The lifted window in the second bedroom serves to relieve the low ceiling height.
I would not like to buy heating fuel for this north-facing building in Wisconsin. Did FLLW sign off on this as is, or was it shelved before it was he had a final look?
Speaking of Stracke being a "suspect" design, how about the George Prout House project (T4811, Columbus, Indiana)? It is a most unusual early Usonian design. The roof points downward on each end of the house and contains a series of windows in between the rafters. Any thoughts?
NOTE: Roderick above is using page numbers from FLW 1943-59 not Taliesin Archive numbers. Although not everything in the Monographs are in these recent collected works books, they at least list Archive numbers and have an Index for page numbers.
Someone pointed out that the fireplace is not in the usual location for a Usonian house ... as part of the workspace mass. While that may be true, the second Usonian (the Lusk House in Huron, South Dakota) had it's living room fireplace located at the far end of the room.
The fireplace location was also criticized as being too close to the dining table: potentially too hot, someone suggested. I don't know, but ten-twelve feet doesn't seem too close to me. Susan (Jacobs) said their family often huddled close around the fireplace on cold winter nights in the first Usonian. Indeed, as children, she said they often raced back and forth in the living room in an attempt to keep warm. Together in the office on a particularly cold winter day at Taliesin West she and I did that ourselves, and I learned first-hand how effective that simple ploy can be, this despite the fact that big logs were burning in the fireplace. Perhaps we have become accustomed to efficient standards of central heating... but Usonians were always on the cool side.
However, from the perspective of the conservation of energy, a fireplace on an outside wall is not very practical in a place like Wisconsin. Inevitably heat is lost through the wall, heat that should more effectively remain inside the structure. And yet, many of the fireplaces at Taliesin violate that simple rule.
On the point of the chevron glazing patterns reaching from the workspace down to the lower floor rooms ... I must agree that they don't seem at all typical of Wright's work. Evdently Stracke was a difficult client ... his house went through several iterations, the second a full five years after the first. It's only a hunch of mine, but I wouldn't put it past Mr. Wright to suggest changes in the first design (which are penned on the drawing), and then telling Jack Howe to see to it.
I've looked through some of Jack's work, and it's quite startling to see how often he employed variations of chevron designs in his houses and in various glazing patterns, some for his own house. Several house designs even have triangular shaped windows protruding from walls, somewhat similar to Stracke. For one example, see the house for Mr. and Mrs. Horace F. Hardy ... second floor bedrooms. Two of the most peculiar window designs I have ever seen.
I was going to comment that the drawings appear in the usual Taliesin format, with module increments clearly marked and a pleasant variety of line weights present, among other familiar elements. We've explored the authorship of presentation drawings, but haven't (to my recollection) addressed the possible distinctions between different working-drawing "hands." Could this pair of sheets be ascribed to Jack Howe as well ? If so, that would provide further evidence of his involvement with this commission.